Quote:
Chuck, I agree with you - but correct me if I'm wrong.. the length of the beavertail is kind of important, as it determines the height difference you need to overcome when loading, or how long the ramps need to be to make up for it.
I look at it as the beavertail + the ramps needed to be " X" long to get the height and keep the angle within reasonable angles. Not the beaver "has" to be this, therefore the ramps "have" to be that. I looked at them as a set and designed from there, keeping in mind the beavertail shouldn't be so low that I scrape coming out of driveways etc. The higher, the better was my guide.
Quote:
If you have a shorter beavertail length, with the same 10° angle, you cover less height. When you couple that with a longer ramp, it should decrease the difficulty in loading.. no?
Yes. It is all in what is a given (fixed constraint) and what can be changed. In your 2nd dwg the longer ramp should work better with different ground levels as it raises the rear end of the car higher than the short ramp as the car passes over the transition. The longer ramp makes for a longer beam in bending (i.e. more flex/lower rated load) the shorter length is stronger and has less capability to compensate for varying ground. There is no right nor wrong answer. whatever works.
Here is the drawing I did for my 9 degree beavertail. In theory, my HF ramps are essentially "in-line" with the angle of the beaver. I modeled my car using 4" ground clearance, which is the ground clearance to my muffler, not my frame. The frame is 1/2" higher. You can see that if I increased the beavertail angle any more, the tail-end would be lower and the ramps would not be in-line. The car would have more issues crossing the transition. YMMV.
My post was pointing out the issue. You seem to have it mostly covered, great!

_________________
Chuck.
“Any suspension will work if you don’t let it.” - Colin Chapman
Visit my ongoing MGB Rustoration log:
over HEREOr my Wankel powered Locost log :
over HEREAnd don't forget my Cushman Truckster resto Locostusa.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=36&t=17766